A plain-English look at the two depreciation methods for plant and equipment and how the timing of your claims differs.
The short answer: same total, different timing
If you are weighing up diminishing value vs prime cost, the key point is that both methods write off the same cost of an asset over time. The difference is timing. Diminishing value front-loads your claims, so you get bigger deductions in the early years, while prime cost spreads them out evenly.
These are the two main depreciation methods for plant and equipment in an investment property. Your accountant is the best person to help you choose. A good schedule shows both methods side by side, so you can see the numbers before you decide.
What is the difference between diminishing value vs prime cost?
Diminishing value claims a fixed percentage of the asset’s remaining value each year. The rate is 200 per cent divided by the asset’s effective life. Because the remaining balance gets smaller every year, the dollar amount of each deduction also gets smaller.
Prime cost claims a fixed percentage of the original cost each year. The rate is 100 per cent divided by the effective life. That gives you the same dollar amount year after year until the asset is fully written down.
Over time, both methods write off the same cost. The real difference is how much you claim in each year, and therefore whether more of the deduction lands earlier or later.
Think of it this way. Prime cost is like paying off a loan in equal instalments. Diminishing value is like paying a bigger instalment first and smaller ones later. The total is the same, but the shape of the payments is different.
A worked example, without the dollars
Take an asset with an effective life of 10 years. Under the diminishing value method, the annual rate is 200 per cent divided by 10, which works out to 20 per cent. In a full first year you claim 20 per cent of the cost. In year two you claim 20 per cent of what is left, and so on, so each year’s claim shrinks a little.
Under prime cost, the annual rate is 100 per cent divided by 10, or 10 per cent. You claim 10 per cent of the original cost every year for ten years, so each year’s claim stays exactly the same.
The first-year deduction is twice as big under diminishing value. In the later years the prime cost claims are the bigger ones. Because diminishing value always takes a percentage of a shrinking balance, a small amount is still left at the end of the 10 years, so it takes longer to write the asset down to nothing. If you hold the property for only part of a year, the first claim is reduced to match, whichever method you use.
What these methods apply to
Diminishing value and prime cost only apply to Division 40 plant and equipment. These are the removable or mechanical items in a property, such as carpet, air conditioners, hot water systems and kitchen appliances. Each item has an effective life, and the ATO publishes the Commissioner’s determinations for those.
Capital works is handled differently. Under Division 43, residential construction generally uses a flat rate of 2.5 per cent a year over 40 years, where construction started after 15 September 1987. You do not choose between diminishing value and prime cost for the building itself.
One more thing to keep in mind. Since 9 May 2017, individual investors in residential property generally cannot claim previously used plant and equipment, with some exceptions such as new residential premises. For many established properties, the choice of method may only matter for new items you add. Ask your accountant how this applies to you.
This distinction matters, because the two systems run side by side in the same property. A proper schedule separates plant and equipment from capital works, so each part is claimed the right way.
Which method should you choose?
There is no single right answer for every investor. Some investors prefer diminishing value because the deductions are larger in the first few years. Others prefer prime cost because the claim is steady and predictable each year.
How long you plan to hold the property can also shape the decision, but it is not something to decide alone. Ask your accountant about your own position. They will weigh up your income, your plans for the property and your cash flow, then recommend the method that fits. Our job is to prepare the schedule, not to make that call for you.
Having both sets of figures makes the decision easier. You can compare the year-by-year claims before you commit, and your accountant picks the one you will use on your return.
How a depreciation schedule helps
Our schedules are prepared by a Certified Quantity Surveyor and cover both plant and equipment and capital works. Your property is inspected by photos and video, with a site visit where needed, and we then identify the depreciable items and their effective lives.
A standard residential schedule costs $600 including GST, with a 3 to 5 business day turnaround and Australia-wide coverage. We offer a free eligibility check first, so you can find out whether a schedule is worth doing before you spend anything.
A clear schedule removes the guesswork. When people ask us about diminishing value vs prime cost, the real question is usually about timing, and a schedule that shows both makes that easy to see. Hand it to your accountant and they can choose the option that suits your situation.
To understand the bigger picture, read our guide to investment property depreciation, or our plain-English answer to how does depreciation work on investment property. If you are still deciding whether to spend the money, our article is a depreciation schedule worth it? gives a simple way to decide. When you are ready, order through our depreciation schedules page.
Frequently asked questions
Does diminishing value always give bigger deductions?
In the early years, yes, because it front-loads the claim. In the later years prime cost gives the bigger claims, and over time both write off the same cost.
Can I switch between diminishing value and prime cost later?
That is a question for your accountant. The method is generally chosen when an asset is first claimed, so it is worth getting the decision right at the start.
Do these methods apply to the building itself?
No. Diminishing value and prime cost apply to plant and equipment only. Capital works on the building uses a flat rate under Division 43 instead.