A payment dispute between a builder and subcontractor is usually won on records, and a quantity surveyor can organise those records into a case.
The disputes that keep coming up
A payment dispute between a builder and a subcontractor usually starts in one of four places: an unpaid progress claim, a rejected variation, a delay blamed on the wrong party, or a back-charge the subcontractor never accepted. They sound different, but they all come back to the same question: who owes what, and can they prove it.
These disputes are common because the money and the records move fast on site. The work is done, the claim goes in, and somewhere the paperwork and the reality drift apart. That is where the argument starts.
Security of payment in plain terms
New South Wales has a security of payment scheme that gives builders and subcontractors a fast way to chase an unpaid claim without going straight to court. It works in a few steps. The claimant serves a payment claim, the respondent replies with a payment schedule, and if they disagree, the matter can go to an adjudicator for a decision that is binding in the short term.
The timing is strict, and missing a step can cost you the claim. The day counts and deadlines change from time to time, so check the current timing for your situation rather than relying on memory. For anything beyond the mechanics of the scheme, ask your lawyer.
What a quantity surveyor brings
A quantity surveyor turns a messy payment dispute into something an adjudicator or lawyer can use. We do three things.
- Quantify the claim. We re-measure the work and price it against the contract or the rates.
- Organise the records. We pull the diaries, dockets, photos and correspondence into a clear order.
- Write the report. We set out the entitlement, the evidence and the amount in a form a decision-maker can follow.
The report is the deliverable that matters. A payment dispute is often won by the side whose paperwork is clearest, and a well-organised report is how that clarity is achieved.
Preventing the next dispute
The best dispute is the one that never starts. Most payment disputes can be prevented with three habits: notice, records and claim discipline. Give notice in the form and time the contract requires. Keep records as you go, not after the argument begins. And make every claim clean, measured and on time.
We work with builders and subcontractors to build these habits before they are needed. A claim cycle that runs cleanly month after month leaves far less to argue about when a payment is late or a variation is knocked back.
Resolved on the records
A subcontractor had a progress claim partly unpaid, with the builder holding money against a back-charge for defective work. The subcontractor insisted the work was sound, the builder insisted it was not, and neither could settle it.
We gathered the records: the signed delivery dockets, the site photos from the relevant weeks, the correspondence, and the subcontractor’s claim. Re-measured against the contract, the subcontractor was entitled to most of what they claimed, and the back-charge was only partly supported. The parties settled on that basis in days. The records did the work, and the quantity surveyor simply put them in order.
Frequently asked questions
What is a payment schedule?
It is the respondent’s written reply to a payment claim, setting out what they will pay and why. Missing the deadline to serve one can leave the respondent liable for the full claimed amount, so check the current timing.
Do I need a lawyer for a payment dispute?
Often yes, especially if the matter reaches adjudication or court. A quantity surveyor prepares the numbers and records, while your lawyer handles the legal process and argument.
Can a quantity surveyor help before a dispute starts?
Yes, and it is the cheapest time to help. Good claim discipline and record keeping prevent many disputes from ever reaching a formal claim.